Does India's first-past-the-post electoral system polarise Indian politics? Should India move towards proportional representation?
Kanika Anabh
Indian polity follows the first past the post system in which a candidate need not secure absolute majority but only a relative majority of votes to win elections.
Polarising Indian Politics
1. Winner does not reflect absolute mandate of people, e.g. in a constituency if a candidate gets only 35% votes and rest get less than this, he will still win 2. Does not give representation to minorities, 'winner takes it all' approach followed 3. Lack-lustre efforts by political parties, as they know that they need not secure an absolute majority 4. Establishes a majoritarian system, leads to polarisation
Has Not Polarised Indian Politics
1. Has been functioning largely smoothly so far 2. Polarisation can also be attributed to other factors such as social media, sensational journalism etc. 3. Is reflective of relative mandate of people, out of all candidates, the one getting even 35% more preferred than others
Need for bringing Proportional Representation
Needed 1. Upholds absolute mandate of people 2. Allows for minority representation too 3. Prevents wastage of votes 4. Already done in indirect elections for Rajya Sabha and President
Not Needed 1. Familiarity with FPTP system 2. Ease of understanding for masses 3. NCRWC suggested retaining the FPTP system
A committee can be constituted again to look specifically into the issue.