Discuss the role of accreditation processes such as NIRF and NAAC in ensuring quality standards in Higher Educational Institutes, and whether they guarantee good quality.
Kanika Anabh
In India, accreditation processes such as NIRF ranking or NAAC rating are used to assess the quality of Higher Educational Institutes (HEIs).
Ensuring quality standards in HEIs
1. Top rankings are only available on criteria such as quality education and infrastructure, inclusive environment, need to maintain that (e.g. Miranda House, top NIRF rank for 6 years) 2. Indicates quality of institution and attracts best talents (e.g. IIT Madras) 3. Sets up an accountability mechanism for colleges to adhere to 4. Acknowledges and rewards best practices in college, motivation to continue further 5. Deviation from set standards leads to fall in rank, feedback mechanism to improve further
However, accreditation is not a guarantee for good quality:
1. Might involve collusive corruption to get a good rank 2. Often standards maintained only during inspection days 3. Parameters for such ranking are not holistic, mental health of students not taken into account 4. Several colleges don't participate (e.g. St Stephens, Delhi University)
Reforms in accreditation along with internal accountability will help in the aim of enrollment rate of 50% in higher educational institutes by 2035.