Explain the differences between Fisher's and Keynesian Theory on money.
Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023
Both Fisher and Keynes treated money as an asset and emphasised [it differently].
| FISHER'S THEORY | KEYNESIAN THEORY | |---|---| | Fisher emphasised that money is used as a medium of exchange. | Keynes highlighted that money is a store of value | | Money is demanded for transaction purposes | Money is used as an asset and is used for speculative purposes along with transaction purpose | | MV = PY where M = Quantity of Money, V = Velocity, P = Price, Y = Output | Md = kY - hi where Md = Demand for money, k = Proportion of income that people want to hold as money, Y = Income, h = Interest elasticity of money demand, i = Rate of interest | | Fisher's theory is called Quantity Theory of Money (QTM) | | | QTM states that increase in money supply leads to a proportional increase in prices. (as V is constant and Y is constant at full employment level) | Keynes stated that increase in money supply would reduce rate of interest which would induce people to hold money as idle cash balances, and thus, reduce velocity. Thus, increase in Ms would be offset by decrease in V, leaving the price level unaffected. | | Fisher assumed AS curve to be vertical, thus increase in AD due to increase in money supply would increase prices only. [a graph of Prices against Quantity: a vertical AS line, with two AD lines AD(M) and AD(2M) crossing it at Po and 2Po] | Keynes assumed AS curve to be horizontal in short run, thus, increase in AD would affect only output (not prices). [a graph of Price against output: a curve horizontal then rising, with two AD lines AD(M) and AD(2M) both crossing it at the same price level, at outputs Yo and Y'] | | Fisher did not consider the role of interest rate on bonds to determine demand for money. | Keynes gave the regressive expectation model to explain the speculative demand for money using interest rates. [a graph of roi against Money: a downward sloping Md curve from a high roi down to the liquidity trap at rc, with Ms and Ms' marked as vertical lines] |
Keynes argued that demand for money(Md) is negatively related to interest rate(roi) on bonds. - When roi is high → people expect roi to fall and bond prices to increase → thus, people buy bonds and Md reduces - When roi is low → people expect roi to rise and bond prices to fall → thus, people sell bonds and Md increases - At very low roi, liquidity trap condition exists and people continue to hold money. Even if money supply is increased, roi will not decrease and thus, will not stimulate Investment and output. Thus, monetary policy becomes ineffective in curing recession as per Keynes.
However, Fisher did not incorporate the behaviour of people and their response to roi. Thus, Fisher's approach is mechanical whereas Keynes gave a comprehensive theory of money by including behavioral parameters and highlighting the speculative role of money.