Topper Copies

Constitutional developments in British India were reactive rather than genuine efforts for good governance. Examine.

Kanika Anabh

The British Empire was known to follow a 'carrot and stick' policy in their constitutional reforms in India, leading to reactive policies.

Reactive Rather Than Genuine Efforts 1. Regulating Act of 1773 and Pitt's Act of 1784, to reduce corruption by East India Company officials and ensure revenues for its shareholders 2. 1813 Regulating Act ended monopoly of East India Company in many goods, in response to fear of Continental Blockade by Napoleon 3. Same act also allowed missionaries in India and education budget of 1 lakh per year, to spread Christianity 4. 1858 Act of Good Governance, or Queen Victoria's Proclamation, was also reactive - Increased proportion of Europeans in army to prevent further rebellion - Labelling Gorkhas and Pathans as 'martial races' to reward their loyalty to British crown in 1857 revolt - Following a policy of 'divide and rule' to curb Hindu-Muslim unity rather than genuine concern for Muslims 5. 1892 India Councils Act allowed discussion of budget and asking of questions after slogans of "No taxation without representation," but many parts still not votable 6. Morley-Minto Reforms of 1909: separate electorate to further divide and rule policy after 1905 Swadeshi revolt 7. Montague-Chelmsford Reforms 1919, to pacify demands for 'self government' being made by Home Rule League 8. Indian Act of 1935, to create federation instead of granting freedom as per 'Swarajya' demand made at 1929 Lahore session of Congress 9. August Offer, Shimla Plan, Wavell Plan etc., to ensure India's involvement in 2nd World War 10. Indian Independence Act 1947, passed in haste to escape responsibility of partition and violence

There were few genuine efforts too: