Topper Copies

The diplomatic and security implications of India putting the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance, and the structural issues in the treaty itself.

Yashaswi Raj Vardhan, AIR 11, 2025

The Indus water Treaty had survived 3 wars, several proxy wars, and complete diplomatic breakdown. However, recently, "put in abeyance", as "water and blood can't flow together" (PM Modi).

Diplomatic and Security implications

Intended implications 1. Raising the cost of terror for Pakistan 2. Renegotiating a more fair treaty 3. Uncertainty = psychological warfare 4. Escalating federal faultlines in Pakistan 5. Economic punishment for sponsors of terror

Possible fallouts/Challenges 1. Unilateral withdrawal: harms India's image as responsible player 2. China axis: Brahmaputra 3. Internationalization of dispute 4. Sets a dangerous precedent in the neighbourhood

River Treaty [a hand-drawn map of the Indus basin showing the western rivers flowing to Pakistan and the eastern rivers flowing to India]

1. Western rivers (Indus, Jhelum, Chenab); for Pakistan [80% water] 2. Eastern rivers for India (Ravi, Beas, Sutlej) [20% water] 3. Grievance Dispute Redressal - Permanent Indus Commission - World Bank Mediation - PCA

Structural Issues

1. Pakistan has 48% basin area, but gets 80% of water 2. Fundamental change: spirit of goodwill & friendship (preamble) 3. Law-fare: weaponisation of Art. 9 by Pakistan 4. No exit clause or modification timeline 5. 1960's realities have changed - agriculture - population needs - climate change

India should defend its stand as per Art. 60 & 62 of Vienna Convention (not a party). And proactively engage diplomatic support from strategic partners.