The Governor's constitutional role in a state's legislative process, the concerns around its misuse following the Supreme Court's Tamil Nadu Governor case, and the reforms proposed to fix Centre-State relations
Yashaswi Raj Vardhan, AIR 11, 2025
The Supreme Court in 2025 has directed fixed timelines for the Governor to act upon state bills (Tamil Nadu case).
Role of Governor in Legislative Process of States (Constitutional) 1. Article 168: defines composition of legislature, includes Governor 2. Article 174: the Governor can summon and prorogue the sessions of state assembly 3. Article 175: Governor can send message or address the House 4. Article 176: special address annually 5. Article 192: decides on disqualification of members 6. Article 200: assent to bills - Money bill: give assent or withhold - Ordinary bill: assent, withhold, or return - Returned bill: shall not withhold assent 7. Article 201: reserve for the President
Concerns 1. Pocket veto! The Governor sits with the bill as he can generally act only on advice of Council of Ministers 2. Dilatory tactics: refers the bill to President for purely dilatory reasons 3. Repeatedly returns the bill 4. Refuses to summon a session 5. Undermining the policy and progress of state 6. Damaging the federal relations by misuse of discretionary powers 7. Governor is not accountable to either state or union legislature 8. Should only reserve such bills for President which: - Violate fundamental rights - Are contradictory to Parliament laws in concurrent list - Curtail powers of High Court
Reforming the Relations 1. Supreme Court in Tamil Nadu Governor case has set guidelines for Governor and President 2. [illegible] appointment of Governor in consultation with Chief Minister (Sarkaria Commission) 3. Reason for referring to President, or by President for withholding assent, to be clearly noted (Sarkaria) 4. Neutral Governor with fixed 5 years tenure (Punchhi Commission) 5. Reserve bills only in rarest of rare cases (Punchhi Commission) 6. Removal of Governor by impeachment through state assembly [illegible]
The recommendations by Sarkaria and Punchhi Commission were re-iterated by Supreme Court in West Bengal Governor case and the Kerala Governor and Punjab Governor cases.
There is need for federal cooperation, not combative federalism. All must adhere to constitutional morality.