Topper Copies

The methods by which Parliament holds the executive accountable in India's parliamentary democracy, and the challenges and reforms concerning parliamentary committees

Yashaswi Raj Vardhan, AIR 11, 2025

The system of Parliamentary democracy was adopted in India to prioritise responsibility and accountability of executive over a stable regime.

There is "separation of power" and a "Doctrine of checks and balances" providing the foundation for a responsible government.

*fig: checks and balances*

Methods of Parliamentary Scrutiny 1. No confidence motion: the Council of Ministers are collectively responsible to Lok Sabha 2. Question hour: members of Parliament raise questions; the government must answer 3. Zero hour: an Indian innovation similar to question hour; "matters of urgent public importance" 4. Censure motion: to censure the acts of individual minister or whole government 5. Budgetary control: money cannot be appropriated from the Consolidated Fund of India without parliamentary approval, esp. cut motions 6. Departmentally related standing committees: scrutinizing annual reports and budget demands 7. Financial - Public Accounts Committee: works with CAG - Expenditure Committee: budget scrutiny - Committee on Public Undertakings: CAG + PSU in general 8. Ad-Hoc committees may be constituted for inquiry into government 9. Other motions: calling attentions, privilege, adjournment, etc.

Challenges 1. 60-70% bills are not referred to committees 2. 1-year tenure of committees is too less for experience 3. Lack of internal capacity of committees 4. Decline in sitting hours 5. Frequent disruptions during question hour 6. PPP model: majority outside scrutiny

Reforms 1. 2nd ARC: refer annual reports of regulators of PPP sector 2. NCRWC: review and reconstitute DRSCs periodically 3. Expert support & internal secretariat for important committees 4. Strict implementation of anti-defection laws 5. Neutrality of presiding officer 6. UK model

A responsible and accountable government is a cornerstone of any democracy.