The grounds and exceptions for disqualification under the Tenth Schedule's anti-defection law, the problems with the Speaker deciding such cases, and the reforms needed to strengthen it
Yashaswi Raj Vardhan, AIR 11, 2025
The Anti-Defection law was placed as the Xth Schedule of the Indian Constitution by the 52nd Amendment Act, 1985.
The law was brought in after experiencing an enormous political instability, especially during 1977-1980 at union level, and 1967 onwards in state assemblies.
Provisions for Disqualification 1. Voluntarily giving up party membership 2. Removal from party on disciplinary grounds like failing to obey 3-lined whip 3. Independent member joining any party after election 4. Nominated member joining any party after over 6 months of taking their seat 5. Merger of less than 2/3rd of party into another
Exceptions 1. Speaker, Deputy Speaker resigning from their party 2. Speaker, Deputy Speaker rejoining original party after demitting office 3. Merger of 2/3rd party into another 4. Removal of member not as per party constitution
Unlike the removals upon disqualifications under Article 102 or Representation of People Act's, which are done by President on recommendation of Election Commission, removal under the 10th Schedule is decided by the Speaker. 1. Speaker is not necessarily neutral 2. Rarely any Speaker resigns from his own party 3. Speaker is not advised by Election Commission
Effects of Delayed Decisions 1. Enhanced role of money power 2. Opportunism and horse trading 3. Gives enough time to secure the 2/3rd benchmark 4. Loss of public trust: democratically elected government is replaced 5. Policy paralysis for said duration
Reforms to Strengthen the Law 1. UK model for neutral speaker: once a speaker, always a speaker 2. Shift decision to President on binding recommendation of EC 3. Allow use of Xth Schedule for whip on only most sensitive matters 4. Prescribe a defined timeline for automatic disqualification 5. End the 2/3rd merger clause 6. Recognise pre-poll coalitions as single party
Recent cases of Maharashtra (2022) and Himachal Pradesh (2024) highlight the need for radical change in the current mechanism.