The constitutional provisions for imposing President's Rule, the safeguards and effects of its proclamation, and the criticisms of its use, with reference to the Bommai, Uttarakhand and Jammu & Kashmir cases
Yashaswi Raj Vardhan, AIR 11, 2025
The provisions for imposition of President's Rule in India are carried from the colonial statute of the Government of India Act, 1935.
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, rather optimistically, remarked that it will remain a "dead letter". However, it has been invoked more than a hundred times.
Constitutional Provisions for Imposition 1. Failure of constitutional machinery, Article 356: when President is so satisfied either on report of Governor or otherwise 2. Centre's duty to protect states against external aggression [illegible] or internal disturbances, Article 355 3. State's failure to comply with Centre's direction, Article 365
Safeguards in Constitution 1. Proclamation needs to be approved by Parliament within 3 months 2. Initial duration 6 months, and extendable by 6 months at a time 3. Shall not ordinarily exceed 3 years 4. Judicial review is applicable 5. Powers of High Court unchanged
Effects of Proclamation 1. Dismissal of council of ministers 2. Assumption of executive powers of state by President 3. Legislative powers exercisable by the Parliament 4. Suspension and possible (later) dissolution of State Assembly 5. Continuity of laws made unless expressly repealed later
Sarkaria Commission noted very high instances of politically motivated proclamations.
Challenges and Criticisms 1. Undermines federal structure by imposing centralisation 2. Politicised, used since 1967 3. Governors skip the floor test of confidence 4. Law and order used as grounds 5. No warning mechanism prior to action to rectify situation 6. Politicised role of Governor
S R Bommai Case, 1994 1. Judicial review 2. Assembly floor test 3. Dissolve assembly only after Parliament approves 4. [illegible]
Uttarakhand Assembly Case, 2016 The court re-instated Harish Rawat government dismissed without floor test.
Jammu & Kashmir case Supreme Court directed to conduct elections as soon as possible.
Despite all criticisms, the significance of Article 356 is that Sarkaria Commission did not recommend its abolishment. It is a necessary tool in maintaining unity and integrity of the country. However, it must be used sparingly, one nation one election would reduce the frequency of its use.