Topper Copies

Why municipal corporations are key to urban governance under the 74th Constitutional Amendment, the resistance of states to devolving power to them, and the reforms needed

Yashaswi Raj Vardhan, AIR 11, 2025

The 74th constitutional amendment Act introduced a framework for urban local bodies. Recently the Capacity Building Commission organised a national workshop to foster a unified approach in capacity building of ULBs.

Municipal Corporations as Key to Urban Governance 1. Decentralisation of power: empowers grassroots decision making 2. Adapting to local needs: the challenges and solutions are unique for every city 3. Effective Service Delivery: water supply, waste disposal 4. Accountability: unlike state and Union governments which may be out of reach, they are local & accessible 5. Bottom-up planning: District and metropolitan planning committees will be starting point 6. Representation of marginalised and vulnerable groups: SC, ST, OBCs, women

Constitutional Framework

Resistance of States 1. Powers for subjects under the 12th schedule not devolved 2. Funds: rely mainly on grants which states are not giving 3. Lack of taxation powers' scope 4. Local taxes subsumed under GST are not compensated 5. Don't have own functionaries

Why States Are Reluctant 1. Financial mismanagement 2. Lack capacity to govern 3. Seen as alternate power centres 4. Inefficient functioning leads to residual burden on states 5. Use of cess by central govt. to reduce devolution to states

Other Challenges 1. Parallel structures: District Administration[illegible], parastatal bodies, eg. Jal Board, Health Society 2. 65% of urban bodies don't have a master plan (NITI Aayog, 2021) 3. Increased complexity of challenges, eg. waste management, air pollution 4. Non-functional ward committees 5. Lack of integration like PRIs; three tiers are not interlinked 6. Lack unity of command: mayor-in-council

Measures for Paradigm Shift 1. Directly elected executive mayor system 2. Innovative funding through bonds 3. Integration by giving superintendence cadre over parastatal bodies 4. Capacity building and training 5. Whole of the govt. approach: uniform integrated local body, hub and spoke connection with other ULBs and PRIs 6. Japan model of glocalisation 7. Merge 12th schedule with 11th, a "local list"

The need for effective good governance can only be realized by bringing global standards to local levels through grass-root democracy.