Topper Copies

The significance of the Lokpal in India's accountability framework, its limitations, and the way forward, following the Supreme Court's recent scrutiny of its jurisdiction over High Court judges

Yashaswi Raj Vardhan, AIR 11, 2025

The Lokpal was recently under scrutiny by the Supreme Court for deciding whether High Court judges fall under its jurisdiction.

Significance of the Institution 1. Very wide jurisdiction under Section 14: all group A, B, C, D officers, MPs, workers and former ministers, even PSUs 2. Search and Selection Committee for fair appointment process - PM, Speaker, CJI, Leader of Opposition, Eminent Jurist 3. Representative body - At least half the members are to be SC, ST, OBC, minority and women - Same for member of search committee 4. High standards of appointment - Judicial: former Judge of Supreme Court or Chief Justice of High Court - Non-judicial: 25 years of expertise and exemplary integrity 5. National level ombudsman with powers on enquiry and prosecution 6. Supervision over CVC and CBI

Not a Panacea 1. Lacks suo-moto powers 2. Lacks jurisdiction over constitutional bodies like Supreme Court 3. Lacks punitive powers 4. Delays in appointment (2013-2019) 5. Too many exceptions for Prime Minister 6. Severe penalties for false complaints, weaponised for chilling effect 7. Post-mortem nature of enquiry 8. Non-uniform extension to states

Way Forward 1. Grant suo-moto and anonymous complaints powers 2. Expand scope to bring accountability over judiciary, link as alternative to Judges Enquiry Act, 1968 3. Functional and financial autonomy 4. Link to social audit reports as mechanism of control 5. Create a synchronised network in states

The institution of Lokpal is a vital step towards public accountability but needs to be accompanied by civic political culture to realise its potential. It is an instrument, not an end.