The constitutional and legal basis for welfare measures in India, the impact of election-time populism and freebies on governance, and measures to address it
Yashaswi Raj Vardhan, AIR 11, 2025
Election season in India is characterised by a myriad of electoral promises, populist jargons and freebies. Such populism narrows governance to winnability.
Constitutional Provisions of Welfare 1. Preamble: socialist democracy, ensuring social and economic justice 2. Article 15(4): prohibits discrimination while allowing special provisions for socially and economically backward 3. Article 38: welfare of people 4. Article 39: equitable distribution of material resources 5. Article 41: public assistance for old, sick, disabled, etc. 6. Article 47: raising the level of health, nutrition, etc.
Legal Provisions 1. MGNREGA, 2005: employment guarantee 2. NFSA, 2013: food security 3. Labour Codes & Unorganised Workers Act
Impact of Rising Freebie Culture 1. Populism over governance 2. Myopic vision in policy making 3. Majoritarianism over equity (vote bank politics), even favouritism 4. Fiscal burden on tax payers 5. Low capital formation: needs long term investment 6. Voters lack agency, treated as passive receivers, no focus on capacity development
Solutions which may work 1. Move to universal basic income model, give individual agency 2. Strict adherence to FRBM Act, 2003 3. Targeted intervention through voluntary refusal model → LPG subsidies, reduces inclusivity error and corruption 4. Social audit of electoral promises by civil society 5. Prohibit extravagant promises under Model Code of Elections
There is need for popular acceptance of ethical governance and focus on human capability building.