Mr. Sharma was the All India Sales Head of a pharmaceutical company with a turnover of 400 crores. The company's main markets were small towns and tier 2 cities. Further, the company did a sizeable amount of business with state government hospitals and health centers. Mr. Sharma had given a lot of freedom to field sales agents to strike deals and negotiate prices with clients. This strategy worked well for the company. Recently Mr. Sharma received word that three company employees were selling products to government hospitals and health centers at a higher price than they were selling to other private hospitals and health centers. The employees were with the company for over five years and were good performers. A few sales staff informally raised the issue of the three getting relatively higher commissions because of their inflated deals. And this was creating a sense of unease among the sales staff. A cursory review of the account of the three showed that, in many instances, the government hospitals were paying more than other private institutions. Under procurement rules, the government is supposed to pay a fair price, one that other cost-conscious customers pay. On inquiry, Mr. Sharma found that the three were not alone; government purchase department officials were helping them scam the Department. Mr Sharma realized that his sales staff and some corrupt government staff had been defrauding the state exchequer for quite some time. Mr. Sharma immediately reported it to his CEO, and the two discussed how to deal with the sales staff and whether to inform the government about the scam and the involvement of their staff. The issue was informing the government means that there was every possibility that they might be blacklisted, thereby losing a lot of business. Mr. Sharma and CEO were caught in a dilemma regarding how to proceed with the case. (a) What are the ethical and business issues involved in the case? (b) What are the options available to Mr. Sharma and the CEO? (c) Do you think the organizational culture of giving freedom to the sales force led to the issue or was the individual's corrupt nature that led to the problem? Discuss. (d) What ethics mechanisms and steps can the company create and implement to prevent unethical behavior, as mentioned in the case?
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
The case presents a classic case of Public private Partnership in corruption leading to crony capitalism
a) Dilemma created are
Ethical Dilemmas and Business Dilemmas
1. Self harm vs social Benefit - Harm to sales worker if reporting of wrongdoing which will save societal resources 2. loyalty to ideals vs loyalty to company - while Mr Sharma has issues with wrongdoing, reporting may make him bad employee 3. ethical ideals vs collateral Damage - Following ethics on own account may lead to job losses 4. Justice for fellow employees VS large issues of 'Esperet de corps in company'
b) Options available
1. To not report the matter
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Safeguard company position | Issue of bad morale | | Personal security to MR Sharma | Not serving society -> Bad reputation | | Forgetting past and mending future | |
2. To report the matter
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Social standing enhanced | Survival of company | | Morale boost of genuine employees | Dent in sales for a while |
c) Sales duping to earn extra commission
Sales duping to earn extra commission is unfortunately common in private sector.
Multifaceted Reasons
1. Corporate pressure to cut deals 2. Demands for bribery by joint enterprise 3. greed to earn extra on account of low salary 4. lack of organisational ethics and values 5. Culture of perform and perish and no stability.
This independence of sales and freedom to deal is one reason but larger reason remains individual greeds as even promotions are based on targets.
b) Company can take various steps to reduce wrongdoing
1. Ethical interview and tests before hiring especially in discretion based jobs 2. Using ethical metric to guide job placement 3. Training and development should incorporate sensitivity training 4. Better mentoring mechanisms - ex 360° performance appraisal 5. Building strong organisation culture - Culture is an impersonal mentor. 6. Performance appraisal should be qualitative - ex Balanced score card
The company should lead by example and build image of corporate capitalism ex Tata's to act as guide to employee's action and build long term goodwill