Topper Copies

A comparison of the Indian and American court systems and their law of contempt of court, including the Supreme Court's recent emphasis on tolerating dissent in a criminal contempt case

Yashaswi Raj Vardhan, AIR 11, 2025

There are over 1.4 lakhs (contempt of court) cases pending against government departments in India. It is often also in controversy for limiting free speech.

Structure | Indian Courts | USA Courts | |---|---| | 1. Integrated judiciary: Supreme Court → High Courts → District Courts | 1. Federal structure: Federal courts → US-SC → circuit courts → US-DC; state courts → state SC → other state courts | | 2. Jury system abolished since KM Nanavati case and CrPC, 1973 | 2. Jury system is used | | 3. Retirement age for judges (SC – 65 yrs.) | 3. Judges for life in SC | | 4. Benches – single, division, 3, 5....13 | 4. Whole SC sits together (9 judges) | | 5. President appoints on collegium recommendations | 5. President appoints, senate confirms |

Jurisdiction | Indian Courts | USA Courts | |---|---| | 1. Integrated | 1. Separate | | 2. Constitutional, civil, criminal in SC | 2. Only constitutional cases in SC | | 3. Can be modified by Parliament | 3. Fixed in rigid constitution | | 4. Procedure established by law (in some case due process) | 4. Due process of law |

Both have certain common aspects 1. Common law system 2. Known for independence 3. Power of judicial review

Contempt of Court | India | USA | |---|---| | 1. Explicit power in Articles 129, 142 and Contempt of Court Act, 1971 | 1. Inherent and evolved power (not in constitution) | | 2. Limitation on free speech, Article 19(2) | 2. Free speech is secured until it is expressly disrupting court procedure | | 3. Criticism outside court ("scandalising") is included | 3. Not included |

Both countries use civil contempt similarly as a tool of enforcing orders.

Supreme Court has itself noted the need for judicial restraint, tolerance and natural justice in a criminal contempt case in India. The court should not suppress dissent, as "Democracy without dissent is a contradiction" (Justice Surya Kant in SC).