The aims behind NITI Aayog replacing the Planning Commission in 2015, and the challenges that have come up in realising them
Yashaswi Raj Vardhan, AIR 11, 2025
NITI Aayog, the National Institution for Transforming India, replaced the Planning Commission (PC) in 2015.
Cooperative federalism One of the central aims of replacing PC was to promote cooperative federalism 1. Bottom-up planning as opposed to top-down or indicative plan 2. "Team India" approach: all chief ministers are members of its governing council 3. Radical restructuring of centrally sponsored schemes 4. Greater autonomy to states in fund utilisation 5. Special vehicles provide think tank support to state govts 6. Competitive federalism: ranking and competing, also fosters innovation in policy making 7. Aspirational Districts, [illegible] and collaboration, eg. PM Gatishakti
Innovative policy making 1. Emphasis on evidence based policy making, eg. NDAP 2. National Development Agenda Document: "India @ 75", "India @ 2047" 3. Programmes like Atal Innovation Mission, Smart City, AMRUT 4. Integrates strategic concerns, eg. Vibrant Villages, e-Amrit (EV), AI 5. Recognising and promoting best practices of states (competitive) 6. Specialist members: expertise
Challenges 1. Lack of funding powers. PC is replaced, Finance Commission is temporary. States' interim needs 2. Nationalising approach of "one nation one x". One-size-fits-all approach 3. Politicisation: combative federalism, meetings are skipped by CMs of opposition states
NITI Aayog is a radical reform in the federal polity of India, but like all systems, its effectiveness depends on those running it. States need to cooperate and grow.