Topper Copies

You are posted in the Department of Mines, and one of your roles is to help your Department Head negotiate mining leases with private contractors. Recently the state government demarcated a new mining zone and planned to invite bids for the mining blocks. You were instructed to oversee the bidding process and speed up the contract negotiations. As planned, the tenders were released, bids came in, and tenders were allocated as per the norms. All this happened at a breakneck speed. You wondered, why the hurry? But it was not your place to think and question; you quietly went about your work. As the contractors were about to start operations, you had to instruct them on environmental concerns to watch out for. And to do that, you read the environmental impact assessment report submitted by a consulting firm hired by the department. To your surprise, the report was shoddy and looked cooked up. You got suspicious and raised the issue with your Head, who politely instructed you to do what you were told, and he reminded you that the Department had revenue targets and was under pressure from the Ministry. After the meeting, you, on your own accord, did some digging and found out that the report was fraudulent and the mining activity that was about to start would lead to a massive environmental disaster which the State could not afford. (a) What are the issues and value violations you notice in the above case? (b) What are the options available to you? (c) Discuss the advantage and disadvantages of each option and identify your chosen course of action. (d) Do you think that environmental considerations are sometimes overrated at the cost of development?

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

The various dimensions of this case are

While revenue enhancement of state is required, it should not be done by having a Faustian bargain with environmental ethics

a) Various issues in the case are

1. Development VS Environment - Environmental degradation as collateral damage to economic prosperity 2. Short Term VS long Term - While immediate benefits may accrue it will lead to long term losses like degradation, disaster. - Uranium mining in Jharsugoda. 3. Personal conscience VS Superior directive - While my ideal of service to the nation asks me to whistleblow, it may violate hierarchy 4. Risk of corruption and collusion of senior and contractors 5. Fiduciary duty towards individuals and communities of the region who are likely to bear the brunt.

b) Various options available are

1. To not do anything and follow order

| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Personal safety as following duty. | Culture of Subsi - against realising my full potential | | Enhanced revenue for the State | Knewer does spell | | Immediate benefits to local community | Motivated blindness |

2. To refuse to give mining license

| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Following procedural propriety ie - Means > Ends | Risk of transfer and even safety | | Holistic action | Attack on IAS [?] by Mafia | | Long Term costs > short Term wins | Anti Development perception |

c) Chosen course of action

However a golden mean between both options need to be stuck. "The choice between for and against is mind's greatest disease." - Buddha. Thus the following action be submitted

1. Preparing the file wholistically and asking Superior's order in writing 2. Using emotional intelligence to convince superior of the disastrous consequences 3. Making the invisible stakeholders visible By liaising with CSO, NGO's and environmental organisation. 4. Encouraging local media and groups to demand transparency around EIA provisions and demanding a public hearing

While rules and regulations need not be violated, they should always be applied with deft. Eg Ashwathama episode in Mahabharata. At the same a civil servant should amplify voice unheard.

d) Are environmental considerations overrated?

IB report said that NGO's like Greenpeace acts as roadblock in achieving India's development priorities. However, at holistic level environment considerations are fair

1. Justice to residents - while development will be important to nation building it will create local impacts eg. Miner's lung disease 2. Aggravates Disaster risk - Disaster will wipe out much more than development gains eg Kedarnath case 3. Value to unborn - "We have not borrowed .... from our inherited children 4. Respect to Fundamental rights - Life Dignity -> Risk from instance like Bhopal gas tragedy.

Thus a holistic, administrative system can ensure better ends through better means.

"There is no planet B". Thus we should have sustainable development