Topper Copies

A certain State government was running a welfare scheme for promoting safe motherhood among rural landless laborers' families. The scheme involves the transfer of funds to the beneficiaries to enable them to mitigate income loss due to maternal care responsibilities. Since its implementation, the scheme has done reasonably well on maternal health and economic indicators. You are the Director of the Department responsible for implementing and operating the scheme. Recently you have been receiving reports of welfare fraud being committed by families by producing fake bona fide. The families committed the fraud with the help of local officials responsible for scrutinizing the bonafide. You were concerned because the fraud was seriously undermining the scheme's efficiency. You called for a departmental meeting to discuss and find a solution to the problem. In the meeting, it was decided to merge several available government data sets such as Aadhar cards, voter ID cards, marriage certificates, birth certificates, bank details, and other personal assets. By merging all the data sets, the department would be able to develop the beneficiary's economic profile. And this will help the department scrutinize the documents and detect fraud. This was a comprehensive strategy, but it risked violating an individual's data privacy. As a Department head, you wanted to detect and prevent fraud, but at the same time, you were apprehensive about violating the Data privacy of the stakeholders. (a) What are the issues involved in the above case? (b) Do you think violating data privacy is justified to prevent welfare fraud? Why / Why not? (c) What, according to you, can be the reasons for such welfare frauds happening in the country? (d) Are there any ways and means to prevent such fraud? Give your suggestions.

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

Schemes like Matru Vandana Yojana provide with cash transfer to reduce pregnancy loss. However we have seen huge leakages in recent years.

a) Issues involved in above case

1. Fraud by citizens - To gain benefits, citizens are ready to violate ethics 2. Corruption by verifiers - Those meant to provide safeguards are hands in glove. 3. Data Privacy - Art 21 gives privacy as FR (Puttuswamy case) 4. Technology as double edged sword - while it can reduce leakage, it can also increase individual profiling and surveillance 5. Means vs Ends - while reducing leakage is a valid end, it is not wise to violate privacy to achieve it

b) Welfare frauds

Welfare frauds seriously undermine the developmental potential of a state given the opportunity cost of funds.

Violating data privacy for larger goal is a classic case of FR > DPSP and have evolved jurisprudence over the years.

Supreme Court in Anuradha Bhasin case has said that privacy can be violated if there is proportionality, a legitimate state aim and legal safeguards. This should be the guide in the following case.

Thus the director should provide safeguards like data anonymisation, data consent from judiciary.

While data privacy needs to be safeguarded, it has to be Balanced with other ideals

c) Reasons for such welfare frauds

1. lack of public morality - Fundamental Duties are not imbibed by citizen - low citizen consciousness 2. Self Interest > Societal interest - It leads to involvement of public servants in corruptions. - Individuals having limited idea of self interest. 3. lack of economic opportunities left citizens and shows their plight 4. Cost of fraud < Benefit of fraud - No punishment to citizens even if awareness about such frauds 5. Easy way to manipulate due to lack of safeguards 6. Concept of public service not absorbed by civil servants. lack of ethical training

d) Preventing such frauds

Such frauds can be prevented by taking a calibrated, multifronged and holistic approach.

Soft Touch measures

1. Sensitivity training of public servants 2. Awareness about public funds to public - Building consciousness of public over public resources 3. Reward the 'good samaritans' by providing social respect.

Hard Touch measures

1. Punishing the recalcitrant officers 2. Use data as tool to create trail of money -> Block funds 3. Disqualification of individuals from all government schemes if fraud detected 4. Building multilevel safeguards - Vouchers cross checking before disbursement

An ethical state should provide benefit to the needy but also double up as strong state to preserve its capacity.