You are a young officer working with the Municipal Corporation of an industrial city. The city was known for manufacturing ball bearings and auto parts. Most manufacturing units were small-scale units with very little production process automation. The units relied on manual labor, which was in abundance due to the villages close by. As the number of manufacturing units grew, the demand for labor increased, bringing in a steady inflow of laborers into the city. This influx of people into the town led to a mushrooming of slums and encroachments on the sidewalks. Once in a while, the Corporation conducted drives to clear out the slums, but after a time, the slums came back. The illegal slums had become an urban nightmare. You were given the responsibility of clearing out the encroachments and slums with the help of Police authorities. As you started the drive, you realized that the people living by the sidewalks were vulnerable compared to the slum dwellers. Many sidewalk dwellers had recently come to the city after selling their properties in their villages. Now if you drive them out, they have no place to go. Your heart went out to them, and you felt that your departmental action was inhumane, but your official responsibilities demanded stern impartial action. You are desperate to find a way to help the sidewalk dwellers without compromising your official duties. (a) What value conflicts do you notice in the above situation? (b) Can an administrator compromise the Value of impartiality for empathy? Discuss. (c) What are the options available in the above situation? (d) Suggests viable solutions for tackling illegal slums and encroachments in urban areas.
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Recent cases related to eviction [?] Khori Basti has highlighted the haphazard urbanisation of India and brought ethical imperatives of the welfare state to forefront.
a) Value Conflicts
1. Right to city VS Rule of law - While Olga Tellis judgement provides right to livelihood it may violate the legal system 2. Empathy to people VS larger interest - While concern for streetwalkers is relevant, it may set up bad precedent and have long term bearing. 3. Following superior's order VS Personal morality - While at a personal level, the order seems unjust, disobeying it would mean abdication of duty. 4. Reason VS Emotion - While reason is realistic and [?] dispassionate, emotion is situational 5. Public Service appearing as disservice - It appears that following codes would violate oath of allegiance
b) Impartiality
Impartiality refers to the quality of not being influenced by different interests, ideas and ideologies even if they are your own.
Merit of Compromising Impartiality
1. Immediate justice - Eg livelihood of dwellers maintained 2. Better use of discretion - Use in public interest
Challenges
1. Sets bad precedent -> Develops a culture of 'alibi' ie Poor courage of conviction to act. 2. Empathy is subjective - Eg Everyone's feel's empathy for one's pet but not every animal 3. Creates instability and Bias - Eg Empathy towards one's caste members -> Destroys merit based selection
Thus compromising impartiality will be detrimental to foundation of bureaucracy
c) Various options available are
1. To refuse order of eviction
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Saves from knower-doer split | Personal risk -> Transfer | | Relief to poor. | Violates ideals of civil service |
2. To undertake eviction
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | long term benefit | Violates vulnerable sections (Art 21 Right to life & dignity) | | Utilitarianism | | | Urban cities problem solving | |
Best option (Mix of both)
1. Providing time period to slum dwellers to make arrangements. 2. Methods to rehabilitate victims for short run 3. Writing to authorities demanding funds for welfare. 4. Following Toofan Singh case, Following legal order should not violate individual rights.
d) Solutions to tackling Illegal slums are
1. In-situ slum rehabilitation - Eg Adani led Dharavi project 2. Better urban planning and data mgt - Eg Regional plans at NCR level planning to address influx 3. Making arrangements through increased capacity - Eg Prefab technology led houses, Affordable Housing and Rental Complexes 4. Holistic policies
| Horizontal | Vertical | |---|---| | RRTS to manage transit across distance | Dual use buildings (Tactical urbanism) |
"Slums are problems not to be solved but managed"
Public servants should highlight the environmental degradation inherent in encroachment. However any action should not violate dignity of vulnerable sections as Gandhiji said strength of state depends on how it treats vulnerable sections