Why do traditions in our society impede change? To what extent can social legislation be instrumental against old customary practices?
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Traditions refers to age old practices that are followed by people successively from one generation to other. Traditions can be both positive and negative.
Traditions impede Change 1. Traditions draw legitimacy from age old scriptures, stories. Thus they come in direct conflict with contemporary society - Ex Recent Hijab issue in Karnataka 2. Traditions are seen as source of identity. Change in them is perceived as loss of culture - [?] Polygamy in Muslims - These universally traditions are an [?] 3. Deeply attached sentimental value - [?] Sikh's reverence for turban 4. Vested interests using tradition to garner self legitimacy - [?] opposition to Protestant movement in Medieval Europe
Social legislation for Change Social legislations have been formidable in bringing change to deep rooted tradition. - [?] Hindu Marriage Act, 1956 removed polygamy
It is again in news due to Hijab issue, Uniform Civil Code and Same Sex Marriage
Benefits of Social legislation 1. Tangible and legitimate counter to orthodox forces - Triple Talaq outlawed 2. Baches change with punitive measures and state power. Basically change by fear 3. Accountability of state institutions created to work continuously in subject - Eradication of untouchability through Prevention of Atrocities act
Challenges 1. Difficulty to impose as not coming externally - Child Marriage 2. Aversion of political leaders - Reversal of Shah Bano judgement 3. It may create backlash and political divide - Sabarimala Issue
However, social legislations are a force multipliers and also duty of ethical state. PM Nehru said that legislation should always be progressive & guide society toward utopia