The principle of impartiality may conflict with the need for compassion towards marginalized communities. Discuss in the context of civil services in India.
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Impartiality refers to operation without bias. However it should not be seen in negative sense but overarching positive sense.
Impartiality 1. No favouritism among citizens → "Treat like alike" 2. Towards political beliefs ('Impartial non partisan') 3. Means substantive justice, impartial doesn't mean value neutral
Objective + Empathy → broader meaning of Impartiality (eg Art 21 dignified living [SC case])
How to apply impartiality so that it doesn't conflict?
1. Objectivity (no bias) and Empathy (treat case on merit): both reinforce each other (eg Bureaucrat understanding issues of tribal through stakeholder consultation) 2. No specialised treatment but collaborative policies (eg Transgender Act and rules through groups) 3. Follow substantive equality (eg Graded response to Disaster → 1st evacuate elderly, children) 4. No arbitrary idea: discretion based on rational nexus and intelligible differentia 5. Kartar Singh case
(eg When eviction, follow Olga Tellis → rehabilitation procedure) 6. Apply law but sensitivities (eg Samadhan → surrender & rehab)
How to bridge this gap?
1. Using Emotional Intelligence 2. Positive orientation and servant leadership model
"The true art in civil services lies in understanding what to stick and what to forgo." This is developed on basis of integrity and compassion.