Goodness is the result of internal imperatives to do what is right, not sanctions from moral rules or rewards from expected consequences. Do you agree? Discuss.
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Plato believed that ethics is about knowledge and once it is achieved a person is bound to be ethical. However Aristotle believed that ethics is not natural and has to be inculcated.
"The Spirit is [?] but the flesh is weak."
Goodness from internal Imperatives
1. Role of individual consciousness - Ex Same-Sex couples despite social bias 2. Goodness even when legal void - Ex People following red light even when there is no law 3. Doing the right thing without reward. - Ex Anonymous donations -> Dasvant concept of 'Sikhism'; langar 4. Breaking law to live upto own standards - Ex Gandhiji in Champaran
However above mentioned view is parochial and utopian [Gandhiji's Ram Rajya]
Sanctions from Moral Rules
1. Social sanctions influence behaviour and one's action - Eg In Indian society, people abstain from drinking in public setting fearing backlash. 2. Sex is taboo but India is highest consumer of porn
Thus goodness is also artificially constructed
Rewards from Expected consequences
1. lying in an interview to get job - Trait Activation theory -> We show traits which give results 2. Impression management - Eg Empathy shown by salesman to gain trust
Human Nature is multifaceted. While in some areas it might be innately altruistic in others it might be artificial. Thus we require strong incentives.