"Man cannot do right in one department of life whilst he is occupied in doing wrong in any other department." Gandhi. Do you think an individual's personal ethics impacts professional life or they both can be compartmentalized? Explain your position with relevant examples.
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Ethics refers to the standards of judging thought and behaviour at the societal level. Ethics are built on individual morality and some other factors, eg Abortion in India is moral while not in USA.
Compartmental Nature of Ethics
1. Differing ideals and standards
| Personal | Professional | |---|---| | Jain chef practising vegetarianism | Jain Chef working in KFC as focusing on duty ethics |
2. Different categorical imperative as per situation - Transactional attitude of business woman but selflessness as a mother
However individuals nature cannot be compartmentalised. Besides humans are social animals - Aristotle.
Impact of Public Ethics on Private life
[diagram: crossed-out sketch labelled "Private | Public"]
1. Societal ideals like woman empowerment and equality getting absorbed. - Beti Bachao -> Improvement in sex ratio. 2. Differential morality as per culture.
| Japanese society | American society | |---|---| | is family oriented | is individualist |
-> Respect for elders [Idea of Interpellation] & Habitus
Private life on Public
1. Different Court judges of USA take on abortion as per their ideology 2. [?] of Corruption -> Kautilya Basis - Socially perceived corruption makes public life
While there can be differential ethics, some fundamental ethical principles are common to all life, society, time like Empathy