Topper Copies

You are the District Social Welfare Officer overseeing the rollout of a new AI-driven eligibility system for a state pension scheme. The goal is to eliminate manual errors and ensure the timely disbursal of funds. Within the first two months, you notice a sudden spike in beneficiary rejections, mostly from rural and tribal areas. Several elderly citizens arrive at your office with rejection letters. Some of them had been receiving pensions for years. They say their names are missing or "data not matching." You ask your team to review the backend. The system was developed by a private vendor and uses automated Aadhaar-matching and income estimation algorithms to verify claims. There's no option for appeal within the software interface, and rejections are auto-processed. Your technical advisor says, "It's working as designed. False positives are unavoidable, but overall, it's more efficient than manual review." However, field reports show rising distress. One rejected beneficiary allegedly died by suicide. You propose pausing the rollout and adding a manual review stage, but are told by the department secretary to avoid "slowing down reform." A media outlet has requested data on rejections, but the vendor insists on confidentiality. You are now caught between technological efficiency, vulnerable citizens, and institutional pressure to show success. 1. What are the ethical issues and administrative risks involved in this case? 2. Critically examine the options available to the officer. 3. What would be the best course of action to take? Justify. 4. Suggest safeguards that should be adopted when using AI-based systems in public welfare schemes.

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

The above case highlights the probable technical snags which have got inadvertently incorporated. On a broader scale, it highlights the importance of value based bureaucracy in a welfare state.

Ethical Issues & Administrative Risks

1. Citizen vulnerability & Rejection letters 2. Loss of only source of Income might lead to acute distress 3. Probable technical errors in system 4. Tech company's reluctance to share data in media (transparency issue) 5. Pressure from secretary to maintain status quo 6. Deciding between over objectivity vs compassion 7. Probable threat to Reforms 8. Collateral damage & suicide (who would be responsible if the case is of technical Error?) 9. Acute stress in rural, tribal and elderly - more vulnerable sections of society 10. Loss of Due Procedure - No Appeal/Review mechanism

Options available to me (DSWO)

I. Maintain Status Quo

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | Will make my senior happy! | Loss of welfare cover | | Keep the 'Tech Reforms' on track | Potential travesty of justice (John Rawls) |

II. Back to old manual system

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | Probably the rejections would reduce | Backtracking on reforms | | Villagers happy | Sets bad precedent for image of district Admin, cost tech usage |

III. Best Course of Action

1. I will temporarily pause the AI based beneficiary system for approval 2. In meanwhile, I will constitute a team comprising of Department and External tech Professionals 3. I will ask the Backend company to get their software Audited by the team 4. Alongwith, I will also mandate a Grievance Redressal/Appeal mechanism be added to software 5. If during inquiry, any malficence is found, blacklist & penalize 6. Also, need to cater to family of person who died by suicide - I will work with District Administration to: - Look into his claims of false rejection - Look into number of dependents in family & criteria in case for Rehab

Safeguards while using AI in public welfare

1. 3rd party Independent Audits before implementation - To check for faulty & biased Algorithms - To check softwares & data structures 2. Mandatory Grievance Redressal [2nd ARC -> Swedish model] 3. Field trials before full on implementation 4. Adaptive approach - Being prepared to deal with uncharted circumstances

"When machines take over us humans; they must not replicate our worst tendencies."