What do you understand by "integrity-based civil disobedience"? Do you think a challenge to personal integrity can be a justifiable cause for responsible disobedience in civil services? Explain.
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
"Non Cooperation with evil is as much a duty as cooperation with good" - Gandhiji
Integrity refers to steadfast consistency to moral principles [?] Yudhisthir from Mahabharata
Integrity Based Civil Disobedience
1. It refers to violation of law as it doesn't conform to moral principles - eg Salt law by Gandhiji to counter oppression 2. It is about placing self ideals over legal sanctions. - eg Edward Snowden leaking classified files
Disobedience by Civil servant for Integrity
Benefits
1. Integrity is a primary value (under APC) 2. leadership by example and living by ideals - whistleblowers Satyendra Dubey 3. Sets examples for other sectors - Encourages corporate governance and ethics -> call out by Francis Haugen
Challenges
1. Bad Precedent - Creates anarchy and chaos 2. Violates categorical imperative - Civil servant's 'Dharma' is to follow the law. 3. Rule of law - While colonial India had different circumstances, in present times we live in a democratic, representative government. 4. Misused by miscreants for personal benefits ; Conflict with law
While civil servant should not compromise with integrity, it should be by better grievance management and application of law
"Integrity is lifeblood of democracy, boost the power in its veins"