While accountability often necessitates documentation, an overemphasis on bureaucratic procedures and excessive paperwork can inadvertently silence the very voices that public policy intends to empower, particularly at the grassroots. Examine the above statement with suitable illustrations.
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Accountability refers to answerability for final outcomes.
Accountability: To whom?
Horizontal: judicial review, role of institution (eg ED, CBI) Vertical: towards hierarchy, towards people who are stakeholder
Accountability to oneself
Necessitates documentation, why? 1. Weberian bureaucracy → based on written work 2. Easy to fix responsibility 3. No arbitrariness, for rule of law 4. Creates long term precedents
How overemphasis seen?
1. Iron cage of bureaucracy (eg Bureaucrat having process orientation) 2. Goal displacement (eg Not disbursing funds impacting millions due to document lapse)
How silences voices that seek to serve?
1. Economic Survey 2021 → rules are masks for discretion, rent seeking (eg Labour inspector → bribe due to myriad of rules) 2. Threat to vulnerable sections → no awareness (eg Reject FRA, 2006 claims due to signature) 3. Exclusion from MGNREGA → due to fingerprint issue → thus no procedural flexibility 4. Banality of Evil: thoughtlessness creates evil (eg Polluting plant not complying shut down → job losses)
How to manage?
1. Go beyond rule → focus on spirit of law 2. Participative governance → stakeholder role in accountability (eg Social Audit)
Accountability ensures means led to end (eg Judiciary over collegium). Overemphasis will create 'Bhasmasurs'.