Topper Copies

Public service requires not merely legal but also morally principled action. Public service requires the public servant to place loyalty to the constitution, laws, and ethical principles. Among the three, which do you think must acquire primacy while carrying out official functions? Why? Discuss.

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

Public service constitutes anything related to public function and duty. From street beat officers to Prime Minister everyone is a public servant.

| Constitution | Laws | Ethical Principles | |---|---|---| | Constitutional morality and doctrine | Specific mandate | Nolan committee and IInd ARC | | Positive discrimination | RTA should followed MVA, 2019 | Empathy, Transparency |

All 3 guide civil servant.

Primacy in official Function

1. Specific law should be primary as it is specialised and subject oriented. - POCSO Act, 2012 should give civil servants while dealing with child case 2. Ethical principles are subjective and if applied will affect consistency of Weberian Bureaucracy - Eg Scheme benefit without documents is bad precedent 3. Law also derives mandate from societal ethics through Parliament. 4. Duty Ethics of Civil servant - Kant says every individual should focus on individual ethics - Eg Ethics of doctor is not differentiable between patient

Harmonise all three

Eg Undertaking court mandated eviction but only following due process and giving time; preparing alternative arrangement while the civil servant should listen to heart where ethics reside. final decision should be of mind guided

[Venn diagram: overlapping circles labelled "Law", "Constitution" and "ethics", with a shaded central overlap labelled "Best Action"]