Topper Copies

Reena is the Ethics and Compliance Officer at a government-owned IT firm with a strong reputation for delivering time-bound tech solutions. One morning, she receives a formal complaint from a female software engineer alleging repeated verbal harassment and intimidating behaviour by the Regional Operations Head, a senior officer widely regarded for saving two failing national e-governance projects. The complaint includes screenshots of inappropriate late-night messages and statements from two interns who were witnesses to an incident. During her initial inquiry, Reena finds that some team members view the senior officer as demanding but deny seeing direct harassment. Others seem reluctant to speak openly. The HR Head, a long-time colleague of the accused, privately tells Reena, "Don't escalate this. We'll fix it quietly. He's too valuable to lose." The Managing Director also expresses concern: "Let's protect the company's image, we've had a clean record so far." There's also pressure to shift the complainant to another team as a "practical compromise." As the Ethics & Compliance Officer, Reena had to take an immediate call before the situation escalated. 1. Identify the ethical and administrative issues confronting Reena. 2. What are her possible options? Which is the most appropriate and why? 3. Suggest systemic safeguards to address workplace harassment in public institutions.

Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025

The above case depicts a sad state of work conditions at the govt IT-company where credible evidence of harrassment is available. Alongwith, Reena also needs to navigate potential talent loss.

Ethical & Administrative Issues

- Potential compromise of Internal POSH mechanisms - Bad precedent setting

Possible options for Reena

I. Ignore complaint & preserve talent

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | Organizational profit | Knowledge spill | | Company's image | Reena would fail out her only job of ethical compliance |

II. Shift the complaint to other team as "Practical compromise"

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | Self preservation | Cowardice Behavior | | Talent retained | Against conscience | | Image of company kept | Against Kant's duty & categorical imperative |

III. Suggested course of Action

1. Temporarily, suspend the accused (send on leave by seizing communication for fair Inquiry) 2. Collect Evidence from various sources and ask Interns to express themselves without fear 3. Emotional support for victim by arranging at home psychological consulting + compensation 4. Upon Inquiry, if charges are proved, immediately fire the suspect and proceed as per procedure established 5. If firing is not in Reena's hand, she should frame a compelling report to top mgmt suggesting strongly the course of action and putting into public domain

"Special place is reserved in hell for those who practice neutrality during moral crisis."

Systemic Safeguards for workplace harassment prevention

1. Clearly pasted POSH guidelines on office premises (Covering definition, penalty, etc) 2. Periodic compliance report submission by companies covering if Internal Complaints committee (ICC) is established or not 3. Creating strong deterrance for future by example setting 4. Awareness generation in employees & periodic training 5. Attitude Change and persuasion by explaining the negative impacts of harassment on female employees

"If a bird is to fly high, how high can it go if half her wings are clipped? We need a new balance between Punish & [?] ahead..."