Topper Copies

Despite recent steps towards inducting women into combat roles, their participation remains low. Examine the key challenges impeding the greater inclusion of women in the Indian armed forces. Also, suggest suitable measures to enhance their participation. (Answer in 250 words)

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

In Babita Puniya case, Supreme Court allowed women to be part of permanent Commission. After that women have been included in various armed roles (eg Col Qureshi and Vyomika Singh during Operation Sindoor presentation).

Challenges for Greater Inclusion of Women 1. Cultural dogmas and gender roles in society -> patriarchy 2. Army culture -> build on macho-masculinity 3. Army (airforce) infrastructure has historical male bias (eg Gunjan Saxena Movie) 4. Difference in physical strength -> needed in combat roles 5. Risk of torture -> fear of outrage modesty and dignity -> act as a chilling effect -> Art 19 issue 6. Costs associated with revamping existing framework 7. Lack of capacity -> train women -> no specialised courses 8. Systemic inertia and structural biases prevalent (eg recent remarks by Army officer) 9. Combat roles -> very niche subject -> inclusion already in other avenues 10. Women -> lack of training -> unable to compete in CDS, NDA exam

Measures to enhance participation

1. Overhaul of infrastructure (eg women toilets, women specific facilities -> like creche) 2. Policy to overcome motherhood penalty; maternal and menstrual issues not a hindrance 3. Training manuals -> SOP's to be developed to highlight 4. Encourage girls -> motivate to join army -> training at school level 5. Response is mix of both, bottom up and top down (eg Army formulating policy -> for integration) 6. Adopt global best practices (eg Israeli female spies) 7. Understand best use -> deploy there (eg Intelligence gathering) 8. Employment beyond permanent commission -> make permanent -> allowed to rise in hierarchy

While inclusion and participation of women in army helps in ensuring gender justice (SDG 5), it should be done in a mindful, scientific, calibrated manner understanding best use case.