Ethical guidance in public administration stems from various sources, laws, rules, regulations, and personal conscience. These sources may not always align. In such cases, what ethical approach should a public servant adopt to resolve the conflict? Illustrate with examples.
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Often in public life, Administrators face a dilemma: to trust external or Internal Sources for decision making as they may be in opposition to other.
Ex: To construct a dam, a river flow needs to be changed. While rules may dictate the officer to do so; his conscience may not allow him and it sabotages lives of villagers.
Resolving Conflict: Law vs conscience
1. Mahatma Gandhi: Argues that conscience is the highest court of justice - So, Administrator should prioritize it 2. Participative decision making - For Ex: In above scenario, DM should consult Gram sabha of potentially affected villages to voice their concerns & send it to govt 3. Compassionate Approach over objective rigidity - Aim: welfare state; not police state 4. Try to do positive use of discretion in an open & accountable manner - Ex: Use of Disaster funds in schooling of destitute children (provided no threat of impending disasters) 5. Follow spirit of law over literal text of law - Needs motivation; clearly following humane SC judgements 6. Using ethical frameworks like Teleology, Deontology, etc 7. Collaboration and Advice from peers, mentors, Senior, etc
If there is a direct and unreconcilable conflict, an administrator should choose conscience; this is cognitive dissonance.