Administrative ethics often involve tension between legality and morality. As a public administrator, how would you handle a situation where legal compliance contradicts moral responsibility? Illustrate with an example.
Raghav Jhunjhunwala, AIR 4, 2025
Ethical domains of decisions have many conflicting interests and often found at cross roads of legal vs moral.
Clash between legality and morality: [a two-axis diagram, legal/illegal against moral/immoral, plotting marital rape, Bulldozer Justice, breaking the salt law, and giving ration to an elderly person without documents]
Navigating tension between legality and morality:
1. Adherence to civil service Ethos and foundational values (as given by Nolan committee) 2. Take guidance from seniors and experienced bureaucrats who might have faced same dilemmas 3. Prioritizing Conscience over outdated/Immoral law - Ex: NO to Encounter as it violates due Procedure even if Political pressure 4. Using Ethical frameworks - Ex: Demolishing a slum to Construct a mall isn't advocated by any school of Ethics (Deontology/virtue/etc.) 5. Learn from teachings of leaders and thinkers - Ex: Vivekananda's (Integral Humanism) 6. Push for legal updation - Sometimes laws may get outdated & need revision 7. Use discretion available; but in written; Committee based decision making and open manner
Thus; as per BR Ambedkar's; how good laws are, depends on the people implementing it.