7. (a) Compare and contrast the contributions of Marx and Weber on social stratification in capitalist society.
Rajeshwari Suve M, AIR 2, 2025
Social Stratification
Social Stratification is the layered structure of society based on differences in opportunities.
Both Marx and Weber advocate for different views of stratification in capitalist Society.
| # | Marx | Weber | |---|---|---| | 1 | Social stratification is exploitative to the workers | Social stratification both functional & dysfunctional | | 2 | Due to difference in haves and havenots | Due to differences in multiple factors | | 3 | Economic determinism is stratification view expressed | Causal pluralism, i.e many causes of stratification | | 4 | Only two classes: ① Bourgeoisie ② proletariat | 4 classes: ① propertied upper class ② propertyless white collar ③ petty bourgeoisie ④ manual labourer | | 5 | The stratification leads to polarisation of the classes | The existence of the middle class in capitalist society | | 6 | Stratification due to economic reasons only | Due to class, status (caste) and power factors | | 7 | Economy becomes base of capitalist stratification | class → economy, power → polity, caste → status (prestige) | | 8 | Advocates single unipragmatic approach | Advocates for multidimensional approach (class, status, power) | | 9 | Can be overcome by revolution | Can't be definitely overcome by revolution alone | | 10 | No stratification in communist society | Stratification may be there in all existing societies |
Hence, both Marx and Weber recognized stratification in the capitalist society.
Their views present different perspectives toward social stratification guiding sociological research in the frame in future.