Topper Copies

5. Write notes on the following in about 150 words each. (e) No society can either be absolutely open or absolutely closed. Comment.

Rajeshwari Suve M, AIR 2, 2025

Open Society is society where social mobilisation is possible without restriction through achievement & merit. Eg class based society.

Closed Society is society where social mobilisation is not or rarely possible as it is based on ascription. Eg caste based society.

However, either open or closed society is not always absolute. This is studied based on case studies and field studies.

Case study 1: David Glass made case study by inquiring over 2000 youngsters. Found that 2/3rd of them attained intergenerational mobility.

Of the 2/3rd, 1/3rd moved upward and 1/3rd moved downward. He concluded that social mobility in class system is immediate class mobility & not long range mobility.

Case study (Field study): M.N. Srinivas studied Coorg society and found they opt practice of twice born seeking Netral mobility. He concluded caste system is not absolutely closed and is open in some ways.

Similar mobilisation is found in [?] process of muslim also. Pseudo mobilization is also studied by Goldthorpe in class system.

Hence, class system or caste system & any other social system is not fully closed, nor fully opened.