(a) Discuss the ethical issues involved in this case. (b) How does the above-mentioned work culture affect workplace morale and productivity? (c) What are the options available to you and how would you address the situation?
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Ans
The case highlights issue of indifference in public service and at same time fight to gain credit. Basically it questions culture of bureaucracy where merit is sidestepped and rewards are motivated
Ethical Issues involved
1. Lack of service aptitude 2. No dedication to service as foundational value 3. Integrity issue -> claiming credit for work of others 4. No positive use of enthusiasm -> Ugly face of bureaucracy (Weberian) curbing individual initiative (Chris Argyris Idea) 5. Difficulty in doing justice -> distributing rewards fairly 6. Maslow Theory -> esteem need of individual as motivator 7. Distrust between Superior-Subordinate 8. Apathy of public servants towards projects -> no creativity 9. Moral Hazard -> Discouraging the doer.
b) Effect on Workplace Morale & Authority
1. Impact on energy level -> fear to take initiative 2. Impact on change in organisation -> create larger resistance 3. Low motivation to join public service -> Wastage of youth energy 4. Toxic workplace relations -> no collaborations 5. Institutional decay (SDG 16) 6. Creation of allegiances for promotion, rewards
c) Idea in Situation
It is natural to feel demoralised and aimless. But one needs Emotional Intelligence to bounce back following the spirit that one is concerned about doing good and excellence in work gets rewarded sooner or later.
Options Available
1. Take a holiday to rejuvenate 2. Quitting public service 3. Complaint to Chief Secretary to claim credit 4. 'Presenteeism' -> Becoming minimum guy myself 5. Being reserved with subordinates
Addressing situation
1. Motivating myself to be resilient & taking a break 2. Continuing working with more vigour as wisdom & knowledge cannot be stolen 3. Positive attitude in working 4. Motivating myself keeping public service in mind 5. Theory of 'Nishkama' karma 6. Long term approach
Sooner or later such work will be rewarded, when development (SDG 11...