2. (c) How does Tumin critique Davis & Moore's theory of stratification? Illustrate with examples.
Rajeshwari Suve M, AIR 2, 2025
Davis Moore theory of the Stratification justified stratification are be functional to society.
They argue stratification is merit based and role based. The rewards are differential due to difference in significance of position.
Melvin Tumin places critical review to their theory.
Tumin critique on Davis & Moore theory:
- Stratification is dysfunctional to society as it imposes & reinforces the inequality.
- No role is higher and No role is lower in the society. Every role has equal responsibility & respect.
Both doctor and nurses are crucial role in medical care and differential rewards are not justifiable in this regard.
- The stratification give unequal opportunities of development. This lead to widening inequality.
- The stratification will demoralise the society and degrades the social aspiration. This lead to failure in role taking and finally end up in chaos.
Hence, Tumin criticize the Davis and Moore's theory in the critical perspective and advocates abolition of stratification.