2. (a) Critically assess the differences between Durkheim and Marx on Division of labor.
Rajeshwari Suve M, AIR 2, 2025
Division of labour is the differentiation of the task. The occupation differentiation is called the division of labour.
Durkheim and Marx expresses different views on Division of labour.
| # | Durkheim | Marx | |---|---|---| | 1 | DoL is functional to the society | DoL is dysfunctional to the society always | | 2 | It is a modern society phenomena | It is a capitalist phenomena | | 3 | DoL is cohesive factor in the modern society | DoL is always exploitative factor in modern society | | 4 | DoL simplifies the complex work structure | DoL is tool of exploitation | | 5 | Specialisation may lead to innovation in the work | DoL lead to monotonous work culture | | 6 | Have some dysfunctions: Anomic DoL, poorly managed DoL, forced DoL | It will lead to alienation of workers: from product, from production process, from oneself / from other workers | | 7 | Can be overcome by professional association, work ethics, etc.. | Can be overcome only by revolution, overthrowing capitalism | | 8 | DoL exists at all levels | DoL exists at Worker - Capitalist level | | 9 | Struggle between various factors | Struggle between haves, have nots | | 10 | DoL is regulated, it is functional | DoL need not be regulated: it need to be abolished, leads to Fetichism |
Both Marx and Durkheim realised significance of DoL and identified its dysfunction.
Thus, views of Marx and Durkheim provide us with both functional and conflict perspectives of Division of Labour.