When it comes to sexual and reproductive health of women in India, rights-based discourse has largely been bypassed not just by the societal norms but also by the legal norms. Discuss.
Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025
In Suchitra Srivastava case, the Supreme Court had held that women have sexual and reproductive rights under Article 21.
However, this rights-based discourse has been bypassed.
By societal norms
1. Patriarchy leading to early marriage, seen as 'dual burden', thus violating right 2. Vicious cycle:
3. Age of consent, marital rape not under society's purview, and thus not given due course
But bypassed by legal norms
1. Justice Verma Committee suggested 16 years as age of consent, to ensure false cases under POCSO do not arise and women can get sexual autonomy, but ignored 2. Supreme Court has asked for marital rape to be criminalized, but not included under BNS (Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita) 3. Abortion beyond 24 weeks sometimes leads to legal hurdles, as there is intervention by committees 4. Family planning programme not updated, and thus no awareness about contraceptives 5. POSH Act (workplace) not acting as a deterrent, as not strong enough (informal female workers out of ambit)
Way forward
1. Explore recommendations of Jaya Jaitly Committee and Justice Verma Committee 2. SC directive in Lata Wadhwa case about recognizing women's contribution, important for their autonomy 3. Sexual and reproductive rights need legal interventions, parliamentary debate 4. Civil society, women's NGOs to mobilize for demanding reforms
'Yatra Naryastu Pujyante, Ramante Tatra Devata': women's respect makes gods happy. Need to do that for fulfilling DPSP goal 41 and SDG goal 5.