How far do you agree with the view that the National Green Tribunal (NGT) has met its objective of ensuring environmental justice in India?
Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025
The NGT was constituted in 2010, and has the mandate of solving cases related to violation of environmental laws, harm to environment.
NGT meeting its objective
1. Delivered sound judgements in cases of violation of laws and harming environment - Goa Foundation case: NGT strengthened, and its verdict secured - Fined Sri Sri Ravi Shankar's Art of Living Foundation for violating environment on banks of river Yamuna 2. With NGT's intervention, district/local biodiversity committees were established in 86% local bodies, against earlier 28% 3. NGT stopped the biggest ever mining contract in Odisha, as it was not as per proper EIA 4. Given monetary relief in various instances of violations 5. Powers from acts like Air Act, Water Act led to a strong stand on pollution laws and their violations
Not met its objective
1. Since its inception, its full strength of minimum ten members not met 2. Bureaucratic members do not understand complex environmental domain, and thus need expert understanding 3. Appeal against its orders leads to time waste and pendency 4. Lacks recovery powers, [?] life still not paid fine, so 'toothless' 5. Government using laws to bypass environmental protection in Korba case of land bypass of tribal
Way forward
1. Providing NGT with full strength of 20 members 2. Capability with resources, expert advice, domain, etc 3. Infrastructure of tribunals to be created as per need
NGT needs to be strengthened, as environmental issue dominate political discourse. SC's guidelines in Oleum case, Almitra Patel case and Vellore case need to be followed.