Both India and the USA adhere to democratic principles but their electoral systems exhibit significant differences. What are the key differences in electoral practices between the two countries?
Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025
India is the largest democracy, and USA is the oldest democracy, and both countries are having election in 2024.
Differences in electoral practices
| India | USA | |---|---| | 1. Parliamentary System, so elections to the House of Commons take ahead for appointing prime-minister and council | 1. Presidential System, so major election for appointing president and VP, ie executive | | 2. President appointed by indirect elections, where elected members of parliament and state assembly vote | 2. President elected by 'electoral college', where representatives of parties hold votes (form of indirect election) | | 3. Rajya Sabha, ie Council of States, elected by state assembly members, and party gets seats as per its rule | 3. Senate, ie Council of States, has two seats each per state, elected directly via state | | 4. Funding of parties was via electoral bonds earlier, now via electoral trust | 4. Funding of parties/candidates via Super PACs, ie political action committee, and corporate donations | | 5. Multiparty system, so coalition politics, pre-poll/post-poll | 5. Only two parties, ie Democrats and Republicans | | 6. People's participation direct, at multiple levels of centre, state, local body election | 6. People's participation at similar level, but high degree of political awareness | | 7. Criminalization of politics: huge money and muscle power, cash for votes, freebies | 7. Political culture is stable and civic, awareness is more; also judicial rule of law strong |
Thus, both countries have different electoral systems and practices. USA has a complicated election process where:
1. Intra-party voting for finalizing candidate in national convention 2. Electoral college votes as per number of votes per delegate, based on population, for finally selecting winning party's candidate
Indian system is relatively simpler and has led to improved participation. We can learn from USA's political culture of healthy electoral politics.