Topper Copies

(a) Identify the ethical dilemmas involved in the above case. (b) Evaluate the options available to you in the above situation. Which of these would you choose and why? (c) Suggest some measures that could be implemented to balance urban development needs with environmental conservation in future projects.

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

The case highlights a persistent dilemma of development v/s conservation in a developing nation

Ethical Dilemma of case

1. Sustainable development and balancing needs of today & tomorrow 2. Environmental and social justice -> equal distribution of costs and benefits of development 3. Political people having horizon problem and need development today as voter's evaluate on that 4. Doctrine of public trust :- Public servant having to take decision in larger public interest 5. Measuring environmental externalities of projects 6. Unplanned urbanisation :- Catching up and reactive approach to development as only alternative? 7. Fundamental right of citizen (Art 14 & 21) as forest is bulwark against climate change. 8. Issues with representative democracy -> what is best decision? Should we decide for others if they are ignorant

b) No compromise on development or environment conservation is possible. So options are for creatively balancing both.

1. Exploring green alternative (eg Cost increase like underground metro)

| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Controlling degradation | Increase in technicality, time, cost | | Long term vision and approach | May not complete by time |

2. Undertaking compensatory afforestation

| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Mitigation of some damage | Time taken for new plants to flourish | | Tree cover reduce population | Artificial plantation not replacement for urban forest |

3. Exploring other alternatives than metro (Recent Economist report that metro only viable in Delhi)

| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Saving of urban forest | Congestion & productivity issue | | Cost reduced | Political class dislike |

| Course of Action | Why? | |---|---| | Is alternative possible, research on it. If Yes -> do that | Best if options which balance Environment and Development (eg Green Buses) | | If No -> Greening this project, also taking compensatory afforestation. Challenge: increased cost, more time to complete | While time and cost more, in long run it will have return of better health. Convince political class for long term vision of development |

c) Approach to balance Urban Development with Environmental Conservation

1. Undertaking Environmental Impact Assessment 2. Nature based solutions (eg Green buildings, passive cooling) 3. R & D in green technology (eg Greentech) 4. Better regulations (eg Building code amendment) 5. Private-Public partnership for innovation & fund generation 6. Social justice -> Environment costs should be equally distributed -> stakeholder involvement

Economic Development is meaningless without environment as it is zero sum in long run. Rig Veda's idea of trusteeship of environment and Bible's stewardship model be followed