Topper Copies

Governors in India often overstep their constitutional role and fail to act effectively when needed. Comment.

Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025

Article 153 of the constitution provides for a governor in every state, and Article 154 states that executive power of a state lies with the governor.

'Long arm of the union with iron glove' - Sarkaria Commission.

Overstep constitutional role and fail to act when needed

1. Discretionary powers under Article 163 are for emergency situations, eg breakdown of state authority, law and order, and so president's rule (Article 356) - But governors use it as per whims and fancies, eg Arunachal Pradesh, or centre's direction for political gain (Nabam Rebia case) 2. Bills have to be withheld or passed for president's consideration under instances like violating position of high court or being unconstitutional - But governors delay bills arbitrarily and stall legislative business - Supreme Court in Tamil Nadu - N Ravi case gave strict warning 3. Appointment of CM when no majority is discretion, but floor test also necessary (SR Bommai case) before dismissing claim - But governors have violated this, eg Maharashtra CM swearing-in 4. Fail to act - Instances of state emergency, special need for funds, eg disaster - Breakdown of machinery, but state is ruled by central ruling party (not fulfilling constitutional mandate) 5. Role as Chancellor of universities also questioned, eg Arif Mohammed case in Kerala 6. Discretionary powers for nominated states, eg Schedule 6 areas, but their mandate not satisfactory 7. In legislative business, governor has to summon house, give starting address, but not followed, eg Tamil Nadu

Way forward

1. Hargobind Pant vs Raghukul Tilak case: governor is just constitutional head, and power lies with CM and council of ministers 2. Sarkaria and NCRWC recommend interstate council for governor appointment 3. Strictly non-party men 4. Define term, qualifications (BP Singhal case)

As held by former PM Manmohan Singh, governors must understand their constitutional dharma and fulfil their role proactively.