While the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) plays a crucial role in combating corruption, its functioning is often criticized for being partisan and acting against the federal spirit. Discuss with the help of suitable examples.
Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025
CBI was established and received powers from DPSE, Delhi police special establishment act, 1946. It is a premier investigative agency of the Centre.
CBI's Crucial Role in Combating Corruption
1. Investigating crimes of law and order, economic violations in various parts of the country 2. Modern resources, tech, forensic, cyber and expert analysis 3. CVC (Central Vigilance Commission) gives/forwards complaints to CBI for investigation 4. Assist Lokpal in investigating corruption related crimes
Criticism: Partisan and Against Federal Spirit
1. Police is a 'State Subject', so CBI is encroaching on state domain 2. Needs 'general consent', but many opposition ruled states do not give it, eg West Bengal 3. Since officials are appointed by centre, they are used by government for political targeting as alleged by opposition, eg CBI case against Arvind Kejriwal 4. State's investigative agencies like Crime Branch, Police, CID etc can investigate similar cases 5. CBI's pendency rate high, and its conviction is low 6. Supreme Court in 'Vineet Narain case' called CBI a 'caged parrot'
Steps Needed
1. State agencies capacity building, so that investigation is decentralised 2. Amending DPSE Act to include relevant accountability provisions in CBI, eg transparency in case allotments etc 3. Role of CBI, CVC, Lokpal overlapping and can be made efficient 4. Constitutional status can be explored 5. Confidence building measures among centre and states by making use of interstate council, zonal councils etc
Thus, CBI has to have a turnaround from 'caged parrot' so that it can fulfil its mandate proactively and work for justice delivery.