Evaluate the effectiveness of the National Commission for Scheduled Castes in safeguarding the interests of the Scheduled Castes in India.
Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025
NCSC is setup as a constitutional body under Article 338. It was earlier a single member office, but 89th CA Act made it a multimember body.
Effectiveness
1. Mandate of investigating, reporting on the plight of SCs done, as it has compiled data and submitted reports to president 2. Taken suo-motu cognizance of various cases - Rajasthan government was called upon on case of death of SC boy - Burning of SC woman in Odisha 3. Provided policy inputs in drafting various laws for SC benefit 4. Power of civil court
However, unable to fulfill its mandate
1. Toothless body, no power to provide relief to vulnerables 2. Appointment under government control, so become a 'retirement chamber' 3. Only takes cognizance and does not act on it, eg Mathras case; it was criticized 4. Condition of SC in working/jobs not improved, still face discrimination 5. Darsana Solanki - IIT Bombay case
Way forward
1. 2nd ARC suggests merging of commission into single one for better control 2. Use interstate council / parliamentary committee for appointment 3. Give more budgetary powers, engage civil society