Topper Copies

The Supreme Court of India has upheld unique asymmetry in India's federalism by intricately balancing centralized authority and regional autonomy. Discuss with the help of relevant case laws.

Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025

Supreme Court in SR Bommai case held that federalism is basic structure of the constitution. India has a unique 'asymmetric model' for its own need and context.

Supreme Court upheld unique asymmetry balancing central authority and regional autonomy

1. In Ram Jawaya case, Supreme Court has called for separation of power, indicating defined sphere 2. In Tika Ramji vs State of UP, it has held that 'Federal list' is important than State list, indicating centre legislations take precedence 3. Centre's control over state during emergency, president's rule has been upheld by court with caveats - In SR Bommai case, Supreme Court held that floor test is necessary and President's rule can be questioned if arbitrary 4. In Govt of NCT vs UoI case, Supreme Court has held that Delhi government has powers but special nature would allow central discretion 5. State's sphere are defined, and role of Governor if arbitrary has been dealt with by Supreme Court in Shamsher Singh case

Thus Supreme Court has balanced the asymmetric federalism. In Ajit Mohan case, it has rightly held that the Centre and State must walk hand in hand, or atleast side by side, for cooperative federalism.