(a) Discuss the ethical dilemma Karan faces in deciding whether to report the incident against Mariyam's wishes. (b) Evaluate the options available to Karan. Which of these options should he choose and why? (c) What responsibilities do organizations like XYZ Corp have in preventing and addressing sexual harassment and creating inclusive workplace environments?
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
The case highlights a daily faustian bargain faced by women in doing their jobs and the micro aggressions they face
Ethical Dilemmas by Karan in reporting on her Behalf
1. Compromise with evil is also evil vs going beyond his duty 2. Secrecy as Mariyam confided in him vs larger benefit 3. Crisis of conscience as vacillating between deciding thing for others or staying silent 4. How much importance should Mariyam get as other women are also stakeholders facing similar advances? 5. Karan's role as friend or crusader of gender justice (SDG 5) 6. Choice of every individual even if bad, or 'moral imperialism' if for good. 7. Who has agency to decide about dignity (Art 21) 8. Quid pro quo exercise may create slippery slope in future 9. Bad means of trust misuse for good ends.
b) Compromise with evil is not an option and thus options are in line with bringing change
1) Motivating Maryam to file complaint anonymously
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | No backlash faced | Chance there might be no action | | Action on the wrongdoers | Reduce weight and gravity of complaint | | Not compromising with evil | | | Setting culture right | |
2) Pushing Maryam to file openly, as she should not let others face what she has faced
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Higher chance of action | Threat to Maryam's job and financial security | | Saving others / empathy towards other | |
3) Undertaking police FIR
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Impartial investigation | Harm to goodwill of company | | Effective and quick action | Loss of business impacting everyone's employment | | | Jumping bus |
Best option for Karan: Flow
As Karan unearthing this is his categorical imperative
Why? 1. Compromise with injustice is injustice and has cascading effect 2. Long term change 3. Punishing the guilty
c) Responsibility of XYZ
1. Formulating internal complaints committee 2. Female participation in workforce enhanced 3. Adequate disclosure of POSH Act, 2013 4. Sensitisation Campaigns -> good touch vs bad touch 5. Free & frank conversation 6. Mental counsellors to solve misunderstanding 7. Anonymity
One bad person spoils repute of entire organisation and thus company should dissociate from such employees
"Only where women are respected, comes prosperity" - Rig Veda
Companies should thus work for dignity of women (Art 21) and help them in express themselves (Art 19)