Q.4 (c) Examine the book view and field view of social reality.
Anurag Singh, AIR 120, 2025
The book view & field view of social reality was proposed by MN Srinivas in context of Indian society.
Basic idea: 1. He highlighted the processes of social change, mobility and jati system that prevailed on the ground. 2. He criticized the [?] to book view as static view of society.
Book View of Social reality
This was propagated by Indologists like G S Ghurye & colonial ethnologists like L. Dumont, presenting Indian society as a static system. The prominent ideas were:
1. Ghurye opined that varna model of caste was spread pan India, i.e all the castes everywhere followed the hierarchy of Brahmin, Kshatriya, Vaishya, Shudra. 2. L. Dumont, in his book Homo Hierarchicus, highlighted the religious root of caste and hence non existence of any social mobility 3. Charles Metcalfe & Indian proposed Indian villages as "little republic", i.e static units which were backward & orthodox.
Field view of social reality
It was propagated by anthropologists like Srinivas, SC Dube, Mckim Marriott, Oscar Lewis, DN Majumdar. Their major arguments were:
1. MN Srinivas through dominant caste concept & jati model highlighted how at ground level different factors like numerical preponderance, land holding play role in deciding hierarchy. 2. Srinivas's idea of Sanskritisation & Majumdar's idea of desanskritisation highlighted the mobility in caste system. 3. SC Dube's book "Indian Village" (1955) & Marriott's book "Village India" (1955) highlighted the dynamic picture of Indian village. 4. Oscar Lewis's ideas of paternalism, rural cosmopolitanism, culture of poverty were also under this.
Thus, book view represents the old & generalized view [?] while field view represents reality.