Q.4 (a) Critically examine the theories of origin of caste system.
Anurag Singh, AIR 120, 2025
Celestine Bougle defined caste as hierarchically arranged, hereditary, specialised, isolated endogamous group. The system that has emerged due to the dyadic placement of caste in Hindu social order is called caste system.
Theories of origin of caste
1. Divine origin: it proposes that caste system was made by god as written in the 10th Mandala's Purusha sukta in RigVeda. It highlights that the 4 varnas were created by god from 4 parts of human body.
Criticism: 1. MN Srinivas highlighted that on ground jati model worked and not varna model. 2. A. Beteille said that it was just a way for sustaining caste system by giving it religious backing.
2. Racial Theory 1. It was proposed by Risley, Ghurye, Majumdar 2. They postulated that varna was based on differences between Aryans & Dasyus 3. Risley proposed classification based on nasal index
Criticism: 1. No empirical evidence backs this. 2. Other societies also have racial intermixing but not caste system
3. Guna or Sociological 1. It highlights that it is the inherent qualities & the predominance of 'guna' that decides a person's varna 2. It highlights 3 gunas and mapped them to varnas as shown below in fig 1.
Criticism: 1. It neglects individual variations 2. It gives no tool as to how to decide the presence of guna
4. Occupational Theory by Nesfield: it highlighted that it was the occupational superiority complex that decided the hierarchy and the occupations were fixed over time due to heredity & endogamy, thus fixing hierarchy
Criticism: some have said that occupation is the result & not the reason of caste system.
Analysis of theories
1. Caste system is complex thus no comprehensive theory is there 2. In Gita & Vishnu Purana it was not closed, thus highlighting its changing nature, eg Valmiki was born shudra but revered as Maharishi with knowledge
Thus theories like Divine origin, occupational, sociological, racial highlight some but not all aspects of caste system.