Q.2 (c) Discuss the framework of operation of jajmani system and its drawbacks, highlighting reasons for its decline.
Anurag Singh, AIR 120, 2025
WH Wiser in his book "The Hindu Jajmani System", based on study of Karimpur village of Uttar Pradesh, introduced the concept of Jajmani system in Hindu social order.
Framework of operation
It highlights a kind of economic model based on interdependence of one caste on other. It has 2 components:
eg Carpenter sharpens the sickle and harvester & in return gets the grain (Karimpur study)
Anthropological view
1. Kolenda, Gould & [?] have highlighted Jajmani system as a positive mechanism which provides economic security, caste councils to protect interests and multiple jajmans for diverse employment sources. 2. Marxists like Biedelman & Oscar Lewis have highlighted the exploitative nature which include unfair power dynamics, pay exploitation and feudalistic system thus becoming a drawback of this system. 3. M N Srinivas has said that it is bi-directionally exploitative.
Reasons for decline
1. Monetization: the introduction of money economy has caused decline as in return of services monetary compensation is required. For instance Langy who & [?] Das (2017) in their study of Rampur, a village in Rajasthan, highlighted this. 2. Shift from caste based occupation has also played a role; G M. Kumar (2016)'s study in a multi caste village near Kanpur highlights the shift. 3. Agriculture is no longer remunerative thus communities are moving out the traditional structures as seen among Patidars of Gujarat (Tichh) 4. Technological advancements like internet, water harvesting measures have also changed dynamics of tivare Baregar
Thus, jajamani system marked by reciprocity is declining with changing times.