Rina and her friends from the college were working as interns with a company for the last few months. On completion of their internship, some of them, including Rina, have been offered full-time jobs in the company. Being a reputed company, she and her friends accepted the offer. Rina is enthusiastic about her new job and has even established good relationship with some of her company co-workers during her internship. However, during her tenure as an intern, Rina had begun to notice that one of the Vice-Presidents (VPs) of the company was giving her too much attention. He used to make an extra effort to stop by Rina's cubicle and chat, something he was not doing with any of the other interns. He had even tried to connect with Rina over social networking sites. Some of her co-interns also noticed this and began to make offhand comments to Rina about the extra attention being given by the VP. Now that she has been hired for a full time position, she is fearful that she might have to work with this VP directly. While he has not done or said anything explicitly inappropriate, the extra attention and the fact that her co-workers noticed it, made her very uncomfortable and undermined her concentration at work. The company encourages an open and friendly atmosphere and when she was hired, it was communicated to her that she should always speak to her Manager whenever faced with any uncomfortable work related issues. However, she is concerned to speak about it officially, as the VP has not explicitly done anything wrong. In the given situation: (a) What dilemmas does Rina face? (b) What options does she have? Provide the merits and demerits of each. (c) Highlight the course of action she should adopt, along with justification for the same.
Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025
The case study reflect a common workplace unethical behaviour that undermines women's safety/security and autonomy. It shows non conducive workplace environment for Rina.
(a) Dilemmas for Rina 1. Job opportunity vs personal dignity: Rina's new job can demotivate her self dignity 2. Personal merit vs fear of favouration: VP might have favoured her for the job on non merit basis 3. Job merits vs poor job conditions 4. Courage to speak to manager vs fear of new action 5. VP's actual motive for over-friendliness vs VP's perception for Rina
(b) Options available
Option I: Rina can avoid doing anything and focus on job
| Merit | Demerit | | --- | --- | | Job security | Potential threat of future mishappening | | No form of confrontation | Uncomfortable at work |
Option II: Rina can directly confront VP and ask him not to be over-friendly
| Merit | Demerit | | --- | --- | | Shows courage | No harm done by VP | | Address the key concern | Shows lack of objectivity | | | Shaming the VP publically |
Option III: Rina can talk to the Manager explicitly and tell her concerns about VP and the work environment - her concerns will act as a warning for VP
| Merit | Demerit | | --- | --- | | Balance emotions with objectivity | She could be removed from job | | Official mechanism to address concern | Non-action |
(c) Course of action Rina should go with option III because:
1. It reflects Rina in upholding the official rules and hierarchy 2. Since Rina has only doubts and not proof for ill action, a warning can act as a deterrance 3. It reflects courage of speaking truth to power 4. Justice approach taken to ensure long term improvement in workplace ethics (as manager will address the concern)
Rana's case is a reflection of need for ethical code of conduct in business houses and a robust grievance redressal. Dignity is the highest form of justice, and it needs to be secured for women.