In a metropolitan city of India, the law enforcement authorities decided to adopt facial recognition technology to improve their crime-fighting capabilities. They implemented a facial recognition system that integrated with existing surveillance cameras across the city, allowing real-time identification and tracking of individuals. The system was intended to assist in identifying known criminals, missing persons, and suspects in ongoing investigations. One evening, a woman reported a mugging incident where the perpetrator wore a hoodie, obscuring most of his face. The victim provided a vague description to the police, and based on that information, the authorities decided to use facial recognition technology to locate potential suspects. The system scanned through hours of surveillance footage from various locations near the crime scene. The facial recognition algorithm generated a list of potential matches, and one individual's image stood out as a close match to the description provided by the victim. The police considered this individual a prime suspect and proceeded with his arrest. Subsequently, it was discovered that the arrested person was innocent. Further investigation revealed that the facial recognition system had misidentified the innocent individual due to the limitations of the technology and the partial description provided by the victim. The police released the arrested individual, still his reputation got tarnished for life. He, alongwith his family, was evicted from their current place of residence. The psychological impact of the incident has been tremendous owing to which his job is also on the line. With reference to this case study, answer the following: (a) What are the issues involved in this case? (b) What measures can be taken to minimize the negative implications of adopting such technologies?
Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025
The above case study highlights the dilemma's surrounding use of emerging technologies that lack of humane touch & empathy and fairness.
(a) Issues involved in case
1. Science without humanity: one of the sins of unethical behaviour named by Mahatma Gandhi 2. Miscarriage of justice: blaming an innocent man shows failure of judicial and police machinery 3. Unwanted / non performance of unethical act, yet paying the consequences of it by hampering of self-dignity, loss of home/livelihood, against the ideals of 'Rule of Law' (victim blaming) 4. Non accountability of technological mechanisms like FRT: no legal measures for wrong judgement in law 5. Main perpetrator not caught: shows rising instances of failure of law and order in metropolitan cities 6. Rising instances of violence / mugging against women in cities (lack of safe public space)
(b) Measures needed for fair use of technology
1. Global collaboration is needed to build standards for use of emerging technologies like AI / FRT / deepfake due to the dual nature of the technology 2. UNESCO's AI ethical standards 3. Inbuilt ethical algorithms in technology, which can reduce arbitrary results 4. Pilot projects to test technology before large scale deployment 5. Non bias algorithms for fairness and justice 6. Localisation of technology is needed, that suits the unique requirements 7. Legal accountability and liability clause to be clarified for future needs (with compensation measures) 8. Appointing ethical officers to oversee the utilisation of technology. Eg: Google's ethical committee
Technology without humanity can result in societal disasters. As depicted in the documentary 'The Social Dilemma' and Black Mirror, we need a value-based technical development.