Topper Copies

Various international humanitarian organizations provide emergency aid in conflict zones around the world. Highlight the ethical challenges faced by such organizations. What are the principles that guide international humanitarian work?

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

Recently, there was controversy regarding work of UN Relief and Work agency in Palestine highlighting bias

Ethical challenges faced 1. No discrimination between victims -> no categorisation of victims 2. Security risks as exposed to violence & conflict 3. Bias in operation 4. Best, efficient and effective utilisation of funds -> Thus no misuse of funds 5. Short term relief or long term capacity building 6. Criterion to allocate ration as supply < demand (eg Famine in Yemen) 7. No quid pro quo with donors and no handling pressure from states

Principles that guide humanitarian work

1. Dignity of individual 2. Even prisoners of war should be treated in just way (Vienna Convention) and universal human rights of all 3. Not bringing own value judgement 4. Not acting as instruments of realpolitik and furthering state interest, balance of power 5. Not acting as fronts for violence, weapon trade, money laundering and intelligence collection 6. Justice to all, equality and equity (eg UN RWA books had anti semitism bias) 7. Principle of Vasudeva Kutumbkam

Humanitarian aid should be in spirit of Sarbat Da Bhalla (Guru Nanak) to make world a better place and not one which is more polarised